The Spectator
28 November 2015 Aus
The pretend war: bombing Isil won't solve the problem
Britain, France and America are in a protracted fight against Islamic radicalism. Pity our leaders have no idea how to win it
Australia
Yellow label
The United Nations’ corporate hatred of the nation of Israel and the Jewish people is clear from the ever-growing list…
Australian Columnists
Brown study
The way some political leaders and the media responded to the terrorist outrages in Paris was fascinating. First, I was…
Consider this …
Hug a Muslim today If the Federal government fails to insist that Christian Syrians alone make up Australia’s…
Simon Collins
If the Aussie dollar could be said to have gone up and down like a bride’s nightie over the last…
Migration diary
Two days after the Paris attacks I arrive in Vienna for a United Nations meeting on human trafficking. Every one…
Australian Features
Clash of uncivilisations
To defeat Islamic fascism, the nations of the enlightenment need to start believing in themselves
Don’t risk bringing in terrorists (again)
The Turnbull coup is impacting upon our national security
Features
The pretend war: bombing Isil won’t solve the problem
The deployment of our military might in Syria will exacerbate regional disorder – and it will solve nothing
Military action against Isis needs a coherent strategy. . . . here it is
Russia and Nato should work in cooperation, not competition. But bombing alone will not be enough
‘They pull a gun, you pull a hashtag’ – the ridiculous debate over what to call Isil
By arguing about rhetoric in response to the Paris attacks, we make the western navel the centre of the action
What Muslims think
The Sun survey that suggested Muslims sympathise with terrorists was misleading
Corbyn’s defence
Naive he may be, but he’s consistent – and at least he’s thinking about the future
‘I was tossed out of the tribe’: climate scientist Judith Curry interviewed
For engaging with sceptics, and discussing uncertainties in projections frankly, this Georgia professor is branded a heretic
How hard should we fight Black Friday?
A meditation on the latest imported festival in the calendar of late capitalism
Sir Ian Botham is a hero – and a fool
It was saddening to realise that the god of my childhood still thinks like a child
The Week
The ringfence cycle
By now, George Osborne had hoped to have completed his austerity programme. Instead, he finds himself making what is, still,…
Portrait of the week
Home David Cameron, the Prime Minister, announced, as part of the Strategic Defence and Security Review, plans for two 5,000-strong…
The many fights over the Lord’s Prayer
Plus: energy use in the age of climate change; home ownership under the Tories; the world’s rarest creatures
True dedication
The true meaning of dedication requires a kind of self-sacrifice not normally found at awards ceremonies
Capitalism for all
From ‘Public loans and private savings’, The Spectator, 27 November 1915: In the nature of things there is no reason for…
Australian Letters
Not Jesus Sir: Damian Thompson (Pope vs church, November 7) is concerned that Pope Francis is compromising “the great strength…
Columnists
The spending cuts Osborne flatly refused to make
Sajid Javid and Liz Truss proposed reductions at Business and Environment that were knocked back by the Treasury
The Spectator’s notes
Plus: Horace Vernet’s North African paintings; charity fat cats; how a Cambridge college refused to treat me as a lady
The French might as well bomb Belgium
As a Muslim cleric has to deny saying it’s OK to eat your wife, the BBC and the liberal establishment just cringe with appalling liberal bias
Is the Archbishop of Canterbury forsaking God?
The horrible events seem to have prompted Dr Welby to question his faith
Get ready: these climate change talks might actually do something
My hope is that the conference in Paris next week will focus less on tub-thumping, more on practical solutions
We must play the blame game over HBOS. How else will bankers learn?
Plus: the Viagra-Botox merger, and memories of Jim Slater
Books
The four men who averted the Apocalypse
Reagan, Schultz, Gorbachev and Shevardnadze are the giants bestriding Robert Service’s magisterial account of the end of the Cold War
Erica Jong’s middle-aged dread
Erica Jong’s entertaining Fear of Dying focuses on the fearsome juggling act of being a daughter, parent and grandparent at 60
Everything you always wanted to know about Sixties pop —and more
LSD, Vietnam, civil rights and the Cold War are all linked to pop music in Jon Savage’s solemn tome about the explosive decade
From cave painting to Maggi Hambling: the best Christmas art books
Andrew Lambirth’s choice includes Berger, Bacon, Bown, and Bawden among many others
K2’s fatal attraction
Mick Conefry describes the occultist Aleister Crowley as being among many sent mad by the treacherous mountain
The best children’s authors of 2015 — after David Walliams
Melanie McDonagh’s recommended picture books feature (outside Noah’s Ark) a greedy pig, an Ancient Egyptian crocodile and some practical cats
The best short story collections — from childish gabbling to jaded nihilism
Short stories from Ali Smith, Nicholas Shakespeare, Lucia Berlin and David Gates, chosen by Ysenda Maxtone Graham
Jack the Ripper unmasked again
Bruce Robinson argues passionately (and a little madly) for his new candidate for the Ripper: a popular musician called Michael Maybrick
Saints and demons
‘The Australian Labor Party is composed of two main factions,’ writes novelist Shane Maloney, ‘Them and Us’. This truth illuminates…
Arts
The bicycle may have triumphed but it’s far from perfect
There are some wonderful bikes on show in Cycle Revolution at the Design Museum but there’s too much slavish adoration too
Artistic taste is inversely proportional to political nous
It’s possibly why Tate Britain’s Artist & Empire exhibition is so thin — and why the Queen’s Gallery display of Dutch masters is so rich
Has there ever been a better time to be a lover of Baroque opera?
In this early music round-up, the Wanamaker Playhouse, Solomon's Knot, Francesca Caccini, WNO and Christian Curnyn's Rameau come out on top
I wanted to beat it with a stick and cry, ‘Get on with it!’: Carol reviewed
Previously I had thought you can’t have too much of Cate Blanchett, but there is a heck of a lot of her here - and she’s mostly stagey and mannered
Why is there no one at the National Theatre preventing these duds getting staged?
Evening at the Talk House is like witnessing a drunk trying to set fire to an ice cube, while Waste is three hours of moral tribulation performed inside a giant Hovis loaf
I’m a Celebrity is like The Simpsons: good if you’re thick; even better if you’re not
The interplay between celebrities in extremis offers such endless dramatic variety and tension you could almost be watching Shakespeare
You can’t forget what Will Self says – even if you wish you could
Plus: how to make a point without saying a word
Culture buff
In 1789, at the beginning of the French Revolution, one of the most popular operas in Paris was Richard Coeur-de-Lion.…
Life
It is political correctness, not maniacal bigots, that will end civilisation
The liberal media are more concerned about the reaction to the ruthlessness of Isis than about the ruthlessness itself
The GP charged around to my side of the table and roved her hand all over my pubic area
Later that afternoon, armed with a wide-mouthed empty plastic bottle, I went to see Mary Magdalene’s skull
The sabs hate us because we’re patriotic, top-rate tax-paying, law-abiding scum
They dream of the day Jeremy Corbyn becomes prime minister and puts an end to wealth creation and good management of the countryside
How do you explain events that even adults can’t understand to a child?
Maybe ‘we’ve got flowers’ is as good a response as any to the Paris atrocities
Essential racing books for Christmas
Horses’ souls, betting coups and SOE heroes: Robin Oakley’s selection of anecdotal treasure troves
Chess Maecenas
Last week saw the death of the city financier Jim Slater. He was famous in chess circles for joining Henry…
No. 389
Black to play. This position is from Basman-Keene, Slater Tournament, Southend 1968. How can Black quickly gain a decisive advantage?…
The Winter’s Tale
In Competition No. 2925 you were invited to submit a short story entitled ‘The Winter’s Tale’. There were lots of…
2239: ITOIX
The unclued lights (all of two or three words, some hyphened and all confirmed in Chambers) can be arranged into…
To 2236: Alphabetical jigsaw
First prize Mrs M. Purdie, Ceres, Cupar, Fife Runners-up Nick Hussey, Overton, Hampshire; K. Parekh, Wayne, Illinois
Mr Spielberg, you cannot be serious
I’m no fan of Spielberg’s ‘serious’ films — his schlockier work had the best approach to the bad guys
The Davis Cup will be one final flourish for Andy’s Barmy Army
Murray may be a one-man band but a British victory in Ghent is all-but assured
Dear Mary: How can I protect my sick husband from his friends?
Plus: how to applaud while drinking champagne, and rock-star etiquette
Sexy Fish: not so much a restaurant as a museum of London’s rich
Richard Caring, Asian fusion’s very own Bond villain, has created his most ludicrous place yet
The rise of the man bun, the Mancan and man boobs
Just at the moment, in the gender-role wars, ‘man’ is attached to more and more things


























































