Some of those pontificating about the ongoing imbroglio respecting the worst behaviour in over a century of Australian cricket appear to have been swept off their feet by Captain Cummins’ hour-plus long presser.
As with everything surrounding this desultory episode, plumping his and the Cricket Australia side before the covers have been lifted has proven unwise. Moreover, it is naive of the many doing so while having never played cricket or closely followed the game.
At first blush, Cummins was brave to front the media and, superficially at least, held his own. As current Captain and then fast bowler in the 2018 side, he has a significant interest in this matter. Still, he didn’t escape unscathed on closer purview especially given his claims of not having recollections of pertinent matters including whole-of-team meetings occurring.
Then came Alastair Cook, a gentleman of the game with runs on the board as a superb opening batsman and former England Captain. With no obvious interest in either side of the argument, he was uniquely placed to reflect. He directed attention to a pertinent issue, namely, what actually happens in the field.
Cook argued that within a few seconds of a ball being roughed up with sandpaper, any professional bowler would immediately notice the ball’s condition and its concomitant behaviour. He emphasised that care of the ball is a full-time team effort for the fielding side. No one would be likely left out of the loop, least of all the frontline bowlers. And that’s on the field, for off it, quite obviously, there are in-depth discussions about tactics amongst the whole team and its coaching personnel. With particularity and context that had been hitherto lacking, Cook noted that dressing-room exchanges along with the fixation on reverse-swing made a broad-based sandpaper secret highly improbable.
If the bowlers knew nothing about what was going on, one potent question arises: with the obvious scarifying of the ball and deterioration of its shine, wouldn’t one or all of the ‘oblivious’ bowlers have drawn its state to the captain and vice-Captain, let alone get a message to the Coach? Perhaps even more tellingly, knowing how quickly bowlers approach the umpires if the ball shows the slightest inkling of losing its ovality, no approach was ever made to them in this case.
On that score, those who have lambasted Khawaja and Warner pointed to the fact that the umpires didn’t notice deterioration. But that begs the question, for we all saw that the hapless, most junior player, Cameron Bancroft, was indeed using sandpaper on the ball.
After Cook came the revelations from 12th man for the match, Chadd Sayers. A fast bowler hoping to break into the team back in 2018, Sayers played just one Test following the notorious one. He is now retired and made it perfectly clear that everyone in the team was aware of what was happening to the ball.
His words are worth quoting, ‘I’m comfortable saying where I’m sitting now that everyone knew what was going on [in South Africa in 2018],’ Sayers said, on a SEN broadcast. ‘It [sandpaper] was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in change rooms … I’m not taking sides; it’s just my recollection of what took place.’
If that first-hand account wasn’t enough, Sayers added that there was a meeting held in the wake of the team being caught with sandpaper, which lasted between 60 and 90 minutes. One apparently that Cummins failed to recall but Khawaja and Warner most certainly did.
But none of this is enough for Cricket Australia. It says it wants ‘evidence’ and so far, to it, there is none.
Exhibit 1 has to be the shoddy enquiry they held at the time where Khawaja and the bowlers weren’t interviewed. Surely getting to the truth would see every member of that team individually questioned. Just what Cricket Australia regards as evidence is unfathomable to any person remotely familiar with that word.
Writing from a mere schoolboy and district level, for the fielding side and all of its bowlers, every member of every cricket team I ever played in between 1960 and 2007 took a great deal of interest in the ball when we were out there.
Bowlers couldn’t wait to get their hands on it especially the red cherry first up. Fieldsmen were next off the rank, for them an absolute privilege to stop it, retrieve it, catch it, inspect it and forward it on to the bowler. Was it scuffed, shiny, knocked about a bit, how was its seam, in shape and so on? That’s before the ball came to me as a bowler where I examined its utility as if my next delivery would capture a wicket.
In my opinion, this debate turns on the fielding side, the 11 players who discuss tactics, handle the ball and scrutinise its state.
I had never heard of reverse swing until well past retirement, and haven’t heard of it since the infamous Test in 2018. Former Aussie coach and great player Justin Langer incisively observed that reverse swing died after that infamous incident. Funny that.
Postscript: Cameron Bancroft has bravely added the evidence that blows to smithereens the Cricket Australia Captain Cummins/rest of the players stonewalling edifice. It remains to be seen whether the cricket establishment of that time and currently will accept the ‘evidence’, fess up and cop the penalty meted out to Cameron, Smith and Warner. Advertisers beware if they continue to filibuster.

















