Unfortunately, for the blue-haired, keffiyeh-wearing zealots of the transgender lobby, Kemi Badenoch is not, as a matter of fact, a bald, just-past-middle-age white man called William Hague. Despairing, I know.
That is not to say, however, that the two do not share similarities. Both became leaders of the opposition following an utterly thumping defeat at the ballot box; they both sought to reinvent the Conservative party in their own image, and they are both particularly adept performers at the weekly Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) clash.
The last of these similarities has, however, slipped the minds of many Tories. Owing to a fair few standout performances at the despatch box, many have been quick to label Badenoch as some type of alpha-ranking beast which devours Andy Burnham on every occasion.
A series of good PMQs performances doesn’t equate to a strong performance at the ballot box
Just look at the Conservative party’s social media if you don’t believe me. ‘Kemi Badenoch DEMOLISHES Burnham’ reads one, whilst another states ‘Kemi Badenoch DESTROYS Andy Burnham’. Apparently CCHQ have hired 2016-era Ben Shapiro to do their comms.
On account of such performances, however, many supporters of the Tory leader have been led to believe that she will win the next general election and, therefore, become prime minister. Sod immigration, the cost of living, NHS wait times, the economy, spiralling welfare costs, crime rates and whatever bloody else – didn’t you see Kemi rip apart the PM last Wednesday?
Words cannot emphasise enough how this is both a remarkably dangerous and indeed complacent mindset to adopt. To conflate a handful of standout performances at PMQs with strong poll ratings is rather foolish.
And this is where one can learn a lesson or two from the now Chancellor of the University of Oxford. Hague had an element of control about him in the Commons. He looked as though he belonged at the despatch box, evoking a certain level of gravitas. Over his time spent as Tory party leader, he had asked 1,124 questions (how many of which were answered, we are unsure) and was labelled by his prime ministerial opponent as possessing ‘wit and humour’.
Time and again, Hague would offer up ‘wisecracks’, providing fuel for his backbenchers to howl with laughter. Chuck in a few sniping comments here and some literary references there, and it appears as though Hague was the model parliamentary performer.
But what came of Hague and his stellar performances? Did he ride a blue wave across the country? Did he trim Blair’s majority down to that of a hung parliament? Did he end up in No. 10? No. In, 2001 he gained one paltry seat. One. At least the Conservatives didn’t go backwards. Though the bar for such an event was frightfully low, given the party secured a meagre 165 seats in 1997.
There was a clear lesson to be learned by such a mediocre electoral performance. A series of good performances at PMQs doesn’t equate to a strong performance at the ballot box. And this lesson is particularly true given Badenoch’s most recent performance yesterday.
Donning a burgundy dress and flanked by two of her most loyal footsoldiers, Badenoch began strong, launching a barrage of attacks against the Prime Minister. In the wake of the recently published Milburn Review, Badenoch’s focus this time around was welfare spending. She began rather bluntly: ‘Will the Prime Minister cut welfare?’
A simple enough question, one would think. Straightforward and no-nonsense. And yet in his response, the King of the North wavered. Burnham couldn’t provide a yes or no, replying instead with some sounds-good codswallop about how the welfare bill must come down in a fair and evenhanded way – whatever that means. Badenoch didn’t seem all too impressed. ‘The Labour party is just the welfare party,’ she bellowed. Her army of MPs loved it, cheering her on from the green benches behind.
Burnham appeared, in no uncertain terms, to be a tad rattled. He retorted that Badenoch ‘doesn’t understand’ the issue of welfare, which made the Leader of the Opposition chuckle but, aside from that, offered up very little. Badenoch appeared comfortable in her position, strutting her stuff and riling up a handful of no-name Labour MPs.
And here is where the lesson of Hague becomes crucial. Because many will see this latest exchange as yet further proof that Badenoch is destined for that fabled black door. They think that the British public will look at her performances in the Chamber and think ‘blimey, she’s got a bit of sass about her, let’s put her in charge’.
But as Hague and his shiny head have taught us, to adopt such a mindset would be naive. An exceptional performance on a Wednesday afternoon is one thing, but offering up a plan to get the country moving forward is another.
Perhaps, then, CCHQ should spend a little less time constructing edits of Badenoch at the despatch box, and more time thinking up ways to beat Labour at the ballot box. Hague may well have retreated from the front lines of British politics, but that is not to say that he cannot offer the Conservatives lessons in how to move forward now. The Tories need not look at Hague as someone to emulate but as someone whose faults can be learned from.












