Grade: B
‘Is that Haydn or Mozart? One can’t always be sure,’ remarks Kenneth Clark in the 18th-century episode of Civilisation, and there’s the British intelligentsia’s relationship with music, right there. Imagine saying that about any other art form, and still passing as a connoisseur. ‘Rembrandt or Poussin? Not much in it, really.’ ‘Michelangelo or Raphael? I can’t honestly tell.’ Don’t be like Kenneth. Brush up on your 18th-century idioms, and rediscover the qualities that make Mozart and Haydn so great – with regular dips into the also-rans of the classical era. I’m talking Stamitz, Dittersdorf, Myslivecek; and indeed Franz Xaver Richter (1709-89), whose music Mozart found ‘charming’, and four of whose 80-odd symphonies feature on this new disc from the Linz-based L’Orfeo Barockorchester.
We’re dealing with the period 1740-60 here, and as symphonic form goes, Richter’s three-movement squibs are fairly rudimentary. But Richter worked at the court of Mannheim – the crucible of the modern orchestra – and there are sudden flashes of playful, passionate originality. At one point he splits his orchestra in two, and has each half playing in a different time signature (drolly, he dubs the result ‘La confusione’). Richter launches a fugal finale with braying hunting horns (even in an age of elegance, the forest was never far from the palace gate) and these period-instrument players are just earthy enough. Best of all, there’s the huge opening movement – a massive fugue, spliced with a driving allegro – of the Symphony in G minor. Baroque and classical styles collide and duke it out; is this the missing link between Bach and Haydn? Hardly, but it’s worth a listen.
Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.
You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first month for free, then just $2 a week for the remainder of your first year.





