Shemozzle (noun): a confused situation; a mess, a muddle. It’s as good a term as any to describe the outcome (or should that be non-outcome?) of New Zealand’s recent general election. Auckland mayor Wayne Brown compared it with a drawn five-day cricket test.
The final result won’t be announced until 27 November, after an estimated 400,000 special votes – mostly cast by New Zealanders overseas – have been counted. In the meantime, the country finds itself once again in a political hiatus.
We have been here before – in fact, many times. New Zealand introduced its mixed member proportional (MMP) electoral system in 1996. Only once since then has the country delivered a decisive majority to a single party. That was in 2020, when Jacinda Ardern’s Labour party swept back into power for a second term.
In every other election for 30 years, the party with the largest share of the vote has had to engage in horse-trading with smaller players in order to form a governing coalition. This plays out behind closed doors, meaning the public has no idea who’s demanding what, or which solemn campaign pledges and bottom lines are being trashed in the process. (For all the virtues claimed for the MMP system, no one ever pretended it was transparent.)
So far, all that can be said with certainty about this year’s election is that little is certain. On paper, the awkward centre-right coalition that has governed since 2023 – consisting of the National party, the libertarian ACT and the socially conservative New Zealand First – has squeaked back into power, but only by the most fragile margin.
Fewer than 4,000 votes separated National and Labour, traditionally the dominant forces in New Zealand politics, in an election in which the two major parties each attracted less than 30-per-cent support. (As an aside, four seasoned political observers at a lunch in Wellington last week, with memories of elections going back to the 1960s, couldn’t recall two less inspiring major party leaders than National Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Labour’s Chris Hipkins.)
Luxon is proceeding on the assumption that he will lead the same coalition for another three years, but special votes could sway that result. Only one seat needs to change hands for parliament to be deadlocked, raising the bleak prospect of a re-run.
The novel element in this election – and the unknown factor – was the emergence of a potential kingmaker in the person of 38-year-old Qiulae (aka ‘Q’) Wong, leader of the Opportunity party, which won nearly six per cent of the popular vote and seven parliamentary seats after attracting a mere two percent (and getting no seats) three years ago.
In the event of a hung parliament, the Opportunity party will hold the balance of power. After repeatedly vowing during the campaign that he wouldn’t work with Wong, Luxon found himself forced last week to pick up the phone. It was a sharp lesson in the realpolitik of the old adage ‘never say never’.
Wong’s appeal is obvious. A consultant with KPMG, she’s intelligent, confident and personable. What’s not so clear is why and how her party surged from nowhere to a position where it could determine the shape of the government. Media enthusiasm was the obvious explanation. The Opportunity party promotes itself as a fresh, centrist force that disrupts the old left-right paradigm. Political journalists identified with the party’s urban liberal image. But the parliamentary newcomers are regarded with suspicion by conservatives, many of whom view Opportunity as a front for an essentially ‘progressive’ agenda on issues such as climate change and Maori sovereignty.
So much for the election night results. But the bigger, long-term issue that has dominated political discourse since then is the electoral system. Commentators who previously endorsed MMP are suddenly asking querulously whether it’s fit for purpose.
‘Is MMP stuffed?’ was the headline on an analysis published last weekend by one national newspaper group, which examined claims that the electoral system had been exploited to distort the outcome for the benefit of National and its allies.
Under MMP, voters get two votes: one for a local electorate MP and another for the party of their choice. Voters can (and increasingly do) vote strategically to maximise their favoured bloc’s chances. In the case of the election just held, critics on the left complained that conservative voters had been encouraged to split their votes, electorate votes going to National and party votes to other parties on the right. The aim was to keep the left out of power.
The split vote campaign had the desired effect. National won 42 seats to Labour’s 36, despite attracting a marginally lower share of the overall party vote. One effect was the creation of what’s called an ‘overhang’ – a quirk of MMP whereby the number of seats in parliament has to be increased because a party’s electorate seats are disproportionate to its share of the party vote.
The question ‘Is MMP stuffed?’ was misconceived, since MMP hasn’t changed. It’s the same system it always was, with the same potential for delivering perverse outcomes. What changed on this occasion was that MMP was used to engineer a result that the left doesn’t like. Suddenly, left-leaning commentators are branding the election result as an existential threat to New Zealand’s political arrangements.
The irony is that it was primarily the left that agitated for electoral reform in the first place. The reformers campaigned on the basis that the previous first-past-the-post system was fundamentally unfair – but just as importantly, they saw reform as a means of loosening National’s historical grip on power. Now MMP has been used against them and they’re crying ‘unfair’.
The truth is that MMP is as imperfect as the system it replaced. It simply substituted one set of flaws for another. Not only can it be gamed by strategic voting, but it defies the P in MMP (‘proportional’) by bestowing grossly disproportionate power on minor parties – a flaw that NZ First leader Winston Peters has repeatedly exploited for 30 years and which the radical Maori party, more than any other, also benefits from.
Tellingly, the media focus has almost entirely been on the supposed manipulation of the system by the right. Little attention has been devoted to strategic voting by Maori voters, who have their own electoral roll and their own electorates. In the latest election, the Maori party won a pitiful 0.56 per cent of the party vote yet ended up with five seats. This distortion was achieved by Maori voters giving their electorate votes to the Maori party and their all-important party votes to Labour or the Greens. Call it a two-for-the-price-of-one deal.
Maori voters cottoned on long ago to the fact that they could play the system to their advantage. That, apparently, was okay; it was MMP working as intended. It was only when the system worked against the interests of the left that the wailing and gnashing of teeth began. Funny, that.
Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.
You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first month for free, then just $2 a week for the remainder of your first year.






