Features Australia

The Human Rights racket

Judges stealing power from the people

21 November 2026

9:00 AM

21 November 2026

9:00 AM

It never goes away. The scheming and planning. The ‘if at first you don’t succeed, try, try again’ resilience. The insistent pressure to take power away from the elected legislature and give it to the unelected judges that is a staple of progressive-left politics. Start by trying over the years not one, but two, constitutional referenda to propose entrenching a bill of rights into our Constitution. Quel dommage! That ploy failed when both were badly defeated, most recently in 1988. The voters, when asked, sensibly wanted nothing to do with juristocracy. So the obvious conclusion these progressive lefties drew – one their cousins proposing the Voice body missed, due to hubris – was simply not to ask the voters.

Perhaps, with a bit of convoluted hocus-pocus judicial reasoning, the top judges might just give themselves a diluted sort of bill-of-rights power to strike down the statutes of the elected parliament on a claimed ‘implied freedom’ basis, despite no known human being with the legitimate authority to frame or ratify our Constitution intending this. And despite the voters emphatically saying ‘no’ twice. The judicial trick here is to talk of ‘implications’ despite no human being implying any such thing. It’s a free-floating, ‘unconnected to any actual human being’, made-up sort of implication – the best sort if you’re in the enhancing judicial power game. Well, we all know we’ve been stuck with this anti-democratic judicial innovation since 1992. It has been kept within bounds for the simple reason that it is so patently illegitimate. We voters did not give this awesome power to the judges. Nope, they gave it to themselves. I know it. You know it. And deep down they all know it too. So they are restrained in how often they use it. (In Australia the top judges, using this implied freedom power, have invalidated only nine statutes since 1992, all but one being Liberal party statutes. Go figure! Compare that, though, to Canada or the US where the top judges invalidate laws with reckless abandon. I lived through this in my native Canada when it brought in its Charter of Rights in 1982, ironically doing so without a referendum or an election on the issue. The result there, and in the US, is that the judges effectively decide just about all social policy issues from who can marry, to euthanasia, to you-name-it. That, dear readers, is what an actual constitutional bill of rights lets rip. And it is that that is the deepest desire not of the old redistribution-of-wealth Labor types, for whom I have some sympathy despite thinking they are ultimately wrong, but rather of the progressive, woke, human rights barristers’ Labor party and Green party types of today.)

At any rate, not satisfied here in Australia with the enervated ‘implied freedom’ power that the High Court ‘discovered’ in the invisible recesses of our Constitution that nowhere said any such thing and whose drafters, we know, explicitly rejected such a judicial role, the progressive lefties here moved on to the next option. This is a statutory bill of rights. These things go under various names, including ‘Human Rights Acts’. But they contain basically the same substantive list of entitlements, of rights, as their constitutionalised cousins. The difference between them relates to how unelected judges get their new-found power. With a constitutionalised model the judges openly invalidate laws they don’t happen to like. (Sorry, ones they deem to be disproportional, unsuitable, illegitimate, not reasonably appropriate, pick-your-favourite adjective for a wholly subjective judgment by judges that amounts to ‘we don’t like this’.) But with a statutory model the judges cannot do this. ‘See’, say the progressive lefties. ‘What are you fretting about? No striking down of statutes now.’


But statutory bills of rights, despite the camouflage, can be very potent indeed.  They have one in Britain and a number of UK legal academics think British top judges are virtually as powerful as US top judges. (I agree, the difference being that I loathe this fact and the UK law profs love it.) The reason why is the two powers that statutory bills of rights give to judges. One is a ‘reading down’ power – ‘you judges do everything you possibly can to read all other statutes in a rights-respecting way’. So what is possible? In a famous British case of Ghaidan the judges there said this power lets them read words in, read words out and ignore the clear intention of the legislature. Wow! Canadian judges strike down the law that says ‘black’.  The British judges read ‘black’ to mean ‘white’. You see the power this gives them now? True, our High Court in Momcilovic has explicitly rejected this level of British lunacy. But who trusts the current High Court that has been over-ruling old High Court precedents on the separation of powers front? Not me.

The other statutory bill of rights power is to issue grandiose declarations of inconsistency. These amount to ‘we judges have looked inside ourselves and we happen to think this law breaches one of the listed rights’. The idea is to put huge political pressure on our politicians. Do they generally cave in? In Britain, overwhelmingly yes. Most of the time in New Zealand, yep. Here, less so. For now.

Which brings me to our states. Victoria, surprise, surprise, was a first-mover in bringing in a statutory bill of rights. (Actually, it was after the ACT but that is like a city council having a bill of rights, so patently pretentious sanctimony.) Then Queensland. And now we have moves in NSW to bring one in. Here’s how it works in the last of these. No notice is given to the voters that the left will enact one of these. Nope. Instead you get a Private Member’s Bill by a Green Party MP, Jenny Leong. Somehow, it’s a mystery unless you’re a cynic like me, this Bill gets taken up for inquiry and report. There are submissions. Some submitters are invited to speak and be questioned at a public hearing – though it is overwhelmingly those in favour of the Bill who get the invite. And now the idea is to get the Premier to let this Bill through. Sort of like what happened in Queensland.

None of this would matter at the state level if the Liberal parties had a single backbone between them. Always and everywhere the Libs oppose these woeful statutory bills of rights. But once Labor (overtly or implicitly) enacts one the Libs never, ever do anything about them. Ted Baillieu promised to repeal Victoria’s. He chickened out. Has Crisafulli in Queensland done a single thing to repeal Queensland’s? To ask is to answer.  No! Do you think Jess Wilson, the woman who favoured the Voice and net zero, will lift a finger in Victoria?

It is on issues like this that we right-of-centre voters desperately need One Nation. I mean maybe – it’s only a maybe – if they hold the balance of power they might force the enfeebled state Liberal parties to do something. (And yes, the Libs at the national level are miles better now than their state brethren.)

But it’s only a maybe. Meantime judicial power here and around the common law world continues to grow exponentially. (Anyone educated in Australia in the last two decades can look up what that last word means.)

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first month for free, then just $2 a week for the remainder of your first year.


Close