Features Australia

Welcome to the Manosphere

It’s not just men behaving badly

21 November 2026

9:00 AM

21 November 2026

9:00 AM

The Digital Duty of Care Bill, currently under consideration by the Senate, has been criticised at length in the pages of this publication. The Bill is a vile assault on our civil liberties, and like all threats to such liberties, it invokes potential dangers which allegedly justify the curtailment of freedom. Among these threats is the ‘Manosphere’ – a term referring to a set of online subcultures and discussion forums in which men discuss gender politics from their own perspectives and in the light of their own experiences. The clear reason the ‘Manosphere’ has been targeted is that many young Australian men aren’t agreeing with the gender orthodoxy that feminist activists in academia, the civil service and the unofficial Labor-Green coalition have institutionalised across the country.

We can’t pretend that relations between the sexes are currently healthy. Dating and marriage are growing increasingly uncommon, and several high-profile incidents in the USA suggest we’ve met a low-water mark. Lindsay Clancy (killer of her three children), Lucy Craig (accuser of the Cornell Seven), and Kristin Knouse (#MeToo defamer of David Sabatini) have certainly been the cause for much discussion, some of it intemperate. Fear of terrorist attacks by radicalised Manospherians is growing, despite such attacks being far less common than jihadist ones and Australia having never experienced such an incident.

I write this to address that fear. I shall begin by disclosing something – I am someone who has participated in ‘Manosphere’ discussions, and I have written extensively, under a pseudonym, for a ‘Manosphere’ website in the past. I attended the 2017 International Conference on Men’s Issues on the Gold Coast. As such I believe I am qualified to write a primer on what the oh-so-spooky ‘Manosphere’ is and why cracking down on it is, frankly, evil.

There are essentially four kinds of Manosphere discussion, and individuals often partake in multiple kinds. Two of them focus on the question of how men should organise to advance their interests within the post-feminist world, and two of them focus on constructing a general theory of (typically romantic/sexual) relations between the sexes. Within the first category are the Men’s Human Rights Activists and the Men Going Their Own Way. Within the second category are the Red Pillers/Black Pillers.


Men’s Human Rights Activists believe in political and social activism as a means to change laws and societal norms. They emerged out of non-radical second-wave feminism and the fathers’ rights movement. They promote giving men the same freedom from sex-based obligations that feminism achieved for women, and complete equality under the law (including in family courts and in the treatment of domestic violence allegations). Whilst Men’s Human Rights Activists commonly argue that both sexes face unfair, sex-specific mistreatment, over time they’ve become more insistent that in the Western world, women are generally the legally privileged sex.

Men Going Their Own Way take a more pessimistic position and see activism as futile, because men who are suffering are perceived as pathetic rather than deserving of sympathy. They believe, either as a means to societal change and/or personal liberation, men should embrace male separatism and avoid romantic relationships with women.

Next come the Red Pillers/Black Pillers, who evolved out of the Pick-Up Artist scene of the 1990s as well as layman research into the scholarship on evolutionary psychology and sex differences. Their goal is to create a generalisable theory of how heterosexual dating, romance and sexual attraction operate. Their general consensus so far is that the supermajority of opposite-sex-attracted women are hypergamous serial monogamists by nature, and that (even if they claim to be against gender roles) they’re primarily attracted to traits consonant with traditional masculinity. As for men, the theory posits the supermajority of opposite-sex-attracted males are polygynous and aim to keep their investment-per-woman as low as possible. The result of these two dynamics is that women are only interested in the highest-quality males, but this gives said lucky men options and reduces their propensity to agree to a monogamous relationship. Mandatory monogamy was a compromise – women had to give up ‘trading up to a better man’ in exchange for men giving up promiscuity (and consequently giving a woman loyalty). However, with the demise of mandatory monogamy, the sexual marketplace is now winners-take-all. Another core argument of this body of theory is that women have two priorities in long-term partners – sexual attractiveness and resource provision – and if she can’t get both of these from the same man she’ll be tempted towards opportunistic infidelity (this typically takes the form of marrying a ‘dependable yet unexciting’ ‘good husband material’ man whilst sleeping with sexually exciting ones). There are multiple divergent descriptions of this dynamic, but it should be noted that whilst it isn’t flattering towards women, it is no more unflattering than the culturally accepted belief that men have their own propensity towards opportunistic infidelity with more attractive women.

Black Pillers extend Red Pill theory, particularly with respect to the determinants of sexual attraction. They argue that for the supermajority of opposite-sex-attracted females, the traits they desire in partners are mostly inborn/genetic, with the core priorities being appearance, height and social adroitness (in practice, this means not being on the autism spectrum). Because the primary traits which trigger attraction are genetic, a subset of men are basically predestined to involuntary celibacy.

I struggle to think of why any of the above should be prohibited. Yes, some of it is unflattering, but no more so than what is commonly accepted about men (What? Most women are primarily sexually attracted on the basis of looks? That’s literally what everyone accepts about most men!). Yes, Manosphere forums have mean and nasty rhetoric – the purpose of which is not to incite but to encourage men to take women off a pedestal and start seeing them as humans rather than angels (not to mention, feminist spaces are full of atrociously dehumanising statements about men). Does it incite violence? Absolutely not. Does it justify removing women’s rights? It doesn’t (and I say this as someone who thinks the ‘Black Pill’ ideology is roughly accurate). But it does suggest that, even in our post-feminist world, it is women who insist men ‘man up’, and that their opposition to sexism doesn’t extend to the benevolent type.

Discordance between the sexes has been steadily growing over the last twenty years, and this is fairly a matter of widespread concern. Despite discontent, most people want romantic love with a member of the other sex, but silencing half the population’s grievances will harden men’s hearts, not open them. The Manosphere is sometimes distasteful, but #TheIck is the price of freedom.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first month for free, then just $2 a week for the remainder of your first year.


Close