Fury: the men blow stuff up, then Brad Pitt takes his top off

Deborah Ross found only one scene of any complexity

25 October 2014

9:00 AM

25 October 2014

9:00 AM


15, Nationwide

Fury is a second world war drama that plays with us viscerally and unsparingly — I think I saw a head being blown off; I think I saw a sliced-off face, flopping about — but is still just another second world war drama. That is, Americans good, Nazis bad, and a man doesn’t become a man until he has abandoned all mercy and learned how to kill. ‘It’s Saving Private Ryan, but with tanks,’ I heard someone say as I left the screening, and although I would never steal someone else’s opinion, it is Saving Private Ryan, but with tanks, and also sliced off faces. I added that last bit myself.

Written and directed by David Ayer (Training Day, End of Watch), this stars Brad Pitt as battle-hardened Sergeant Don ‘Wardaddy’ Collier who commands a Sherman tank. He is an interesting character at the outset — unsympathetic; falls apart when his men aren’t looking — but ultimately conforms as a regular hero by the end. Courage against all the odds. The glorious nature of macho self-sacrifice. This is what he believes in, ultimately (his tank has ‘Fury’ graffitied in white paint on its thrusting gun barrel which probably says it all, most phallically). He leads a five-man crew. The men are Shia LaBeouf as ‘Bible’, who is a committed Christian, and Michael Pena as ‘Gordo’, the obligatory non-white, Jon Bernthal as ‘Coon-Ass’, the southern redneck with bad teeth, and new recruit Norman (Logan Lerman), who has been seconded by mistake (he is a typist). Norman is the archetypal new recruit: young, innocent, fearful. He has yet even to fire a gun. He doesn’t know about abandoning all mercy and learning how to kill, but he will, obviously. It’ll be a steep learning curve, but he’ll get there. (In this regard, I had faith in Norman, right from the off.)

Brad Pitt;Shia LaBeouf;Logan Lerman;Michael Pena;Jon Bernthal
Brad Pitt with the crew of the Sherman tank, Fury

These are men who would never encounter each other in civilian life but, hunkered down in the sweaty, dirty, claustrophobic tank decorated with appropriated Nazi memorabilia — I’ve never seen this look in Elle Decoration, but it sort of works — they tightly bond. You thought they wouldn’t tightly bond? Have you seen any war films at all? Start with Where Eagles Dare and work your way up. It may even be that all war films are Where Eagles Dare, now served with mighty dollops of gore. Just putting that out there.

This is set in the waning days of the war, when the Allied troops have effectively won, but are still pushing though Germany as Germany throws everything at them, including child soldiers, and the SS are stringing up anyone who refuses to fight. At no point do any of the men question what they are being asked to do, or reflect on the idiocy of possibly having to die for a war that is over. It is resolutely non-ironic. The battle scenes are extremely well-mounted, technically impressive, and wholly unforgiving. There is mud and blood. A Nazi is stabbed through the eye. There’s the rat-at-at-at-at of machine guns. There are tanks running over bodies. There are explosions lighting the night sky, but otherwise it illuminates nothing. I couldn’t even figure out what it might be trying to illuminate, or even if it was trying to illuminate anything at all.

Brad Pitt;Shia LaBeouf;Logan Lerman;Michael Pena;Jon Bernthal

There is only one scene of any complexity. It occurs when the Allied forces take a small German town, and Collier and his crew impose themselves on a German woman and her pretty young cousin in their apartment. The men are abusive but also not abusive, they terrorise but also don’t terrorise. It was more tense than any of the fighting, and also introduced an unsettling ambiguity. The brutality of war may cost those who fight in it their humanity, but to what extent? Can you lose some of it, but not all? Can you ever retrieve that which has been lost? But this scene is self-contained; the film carries on afterwards as if it never happened, and the men simply return to blowing stuff up, although not before Pitt has taken his top off. You thought he wouldn’t take his top off? Have you seen any Brad Pitt films at all?

It is well-performed, and the script is spare, for which we should probably be thankful, as some of the lines are truly awful. ‘Ideals are peaceful, history is violent,’ says Pitt, who doesn’t say much, and then says something meaningless meaningfully. (He is quite Zen-like in this way.) But the characters are underwritten, the score is overbearing. And the ‘true horror of war’ as a theme, has, dare I say it, been rather done to death. It is viscerally thrilling, if you are after visceral thrills, but otherwise you will be asking: and your point is?

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10

Show comments
  • Paddy Kilshamus

    From a Hollywood insider, sort of I hear that Brad Pitt is to star in ‘Hellstorm’ based on the book by Thomas Goodrich. He plays Ilya Ehrenburg the chief propagandist of Soviet Russian forces who wrote:

    ‘The Germans are not human beings. From now on, the word “German” is the most horrible curse. From now on, the word “German” strikes us to the quick. We have nothing to discuss. We will not get excited. We will kill. If you have not killed at least one German a day, you have wasted that day… If you cannot kill a German with a bullet, then kill him with your bayonet. If your part of the front is quiet and there is no fighting, then kill a German in the meantime… If you have already killed a German, then kill another one–there is nothing more amusing to us than a heap of German corpses. Don’t count the days, don’t count the kilometers. Count only one thing: the number of Germans you have killed. Kill the Germans! Kill the Germans! Kill!’

    It should be very good especially as they have Ben Kingsley starring as Stalin in a reprise of his psycho role in ‘Sexy Beast’ and Juliet Stevenson as one of the millions of German women raped by order of Iyla again:

    ‘Kill! Kill! In the German race there is nothing but evil; not one among the living, not one among the yet unborn but is evil! Follow the precepts of Comrade Stalin. Stamp out the fascist beast once and for all in its lair! Use force and break the racial pride of these German women. Take them as your lawful booty. Kill! As you storm onward, kill, you gallant soldiers of the Red Army’

    Lucky thing we decided to team up with the Russians or that might have been visited upon us. Sounds gruesome.Can’t wait to see it!

  • HD2

    1. Fury is the best film I’ve seen in a decade – by a country mile better than (eg) Avatar
    2. The line about horses & flies in Normandy precisely echoes my own father’s account (he was a Col Sgt in a recce group)
    3. Murray Walker (F1) was a captain in a Sherman tank in WW2
    4. The last scene is not remotely credible, but the rest is a typical Holywood account.
    5. It’s the first US made film I can recall showing a US war-crime (again, mirroring my father’s account)

    • Dan Lee

      Watch Platoon.

      Warch more films in general.

      This movie was so generic. A big dumb action pretending to be a study on war.

      • HD2

        I agree with the generic point.
        What’s the problem with that, though?

    • Tylendal

      Just have to share something in response to point number 5. Personally, the end of the movie stretched my suspension of disbelief… but they do say truth is stranger than fiction.
      I learned a few days later, that that exact scenario had happened in World War II, flaming, immobilized tank, army of Nazis, pintle mounted gun, the works. Look up Audie Murphy.

      • HD2

        I knew Audie Murphy had kept a squadron of German tanks at bay in summer 1945 almost single-handed with a .50 cal machine gun.
        I did NOT know he was in an (immobilised) tank at the time.

        Thank you!

  • iDonald

    I think the writer missed the point of the film, probably from being overly sophisticated.

    • Miles Robinson

      … and a woman! Not really a sensible choice of reviewer since it’s not aimed at them.

  • Ryan Fisher

    Just sit back and enjoy the movie; that’s what they’re there for. I feel truly blessed that I don’t have to watch a film with all cylinders pumping trying to overanalyze why the tank went left and not right. If you want art go look at paintings, if you want in depth thematic sequencing go read a book. Films are for entertainment.

    FYI, I thought the film was incredible.

  • trace9

    The Pitts in a tank – you’ve gaat to be choking! – Pitty not done at birth; yet more w”nkers at war..