Arts feature

Meet the fans who risk death for heavy metal

Why do authoritarian regimes fear metalheads? Karen Yossman goes on tour with Iron Maiden on their first visit to China to find out

14 May 2016

9:00 AM

14 May 2016

9:00 AM

With its loud guitar riffs and even louder fashion, heavy metal has always been ripe for ridicule. In its mid-1980s heyday, it was epitomised by the fictional rock group Spinal Tap prancing on stage next to an 18-inch polystyrene model of Stonehenge while clad in ball-crushingly tight trousers and floor-length capes.

In some parts of the world, however, metal is no laughing matter. In the Middle East, for instance, the potential punishment for wearing all black while wielding an electric guitar is death. These days, against a backdrop of authoritarian suppression in countries such as Iran and China, heavy metal’s trademark theatrics and widdly guitar solos have become less an opportunity for gentle mockery than a rallying cry for artistic freedom.

If all this sounds about as bombastic as the lyrics to Manowar’s ‘Die for Metal’ (chorus: ‘They can’t stop us, let ’em try, for heavy metal we will die!’), it is worth noting that historians now credit rock’n’roll as being instrumental — pun intended — in bringing about the collapse of the Soviet Union. Not only did bands such as the Beatles counter communist propaganda by humanising the West; for many Soviet teenagers (including my Lithuanian-born father), buying illicit, black-market ‘bone records’ — bootlegs printed on discarded X-rays — gave them their first taste of rebellion and set many on a path to dissidence.

So it’s no surprise that, while some in the West might consider it a bit of a joke, today’s authoritarian regimes are downright fearful of metal, a darker and more aggressive subgenre of rock that first emerged in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Although the origins of the term ‘heavy metal’ are murky, its initial usage, according to American sociologist Deena Weinstein, was almost certainly pejorative. In the scientific sense, ‘heavy metal’ was a synonym for mercury, which, in the 1960s, was ‘polluting the air and poisoning fish and those who ate them’. Adopting the label cemented the genre as a counterculture in which outward displays of non-conformity — tattoos, piercings, long hair for men — became symbols of solidarity.

Which is presumably why, when the reigning kings of heavy metal, Iron Maiden, performed for the first time in China last month — an experience frontman Bruce Dickinson compared to playing communist Poland in 1984 — they were handed a set of seemingly arbitrary rules, including a ban on waving the British flag (which Dickinson usually does during his rendition of the 1983 hit ‘The Trooper’), while audience members were forbidden to take pictures. Fifty-seven-year-old Dickinson’s response was to tell the baying crowd in Shanghai, ‘Do I care? Everybody take out your camera device — take a picture.’ He even pretended to wave an imaginary flag. Nor did he shy away from delivering his customary introduction to the title track from the new album, The Book of Souls, ostensibly about the Mayans. ‘Empires always go,’ he said ominously. ‘There has never been one that has lasted more than a couple of thousand years. You just have to wait a while before it disappears.’

For Chinese nationals, especially those living in the austere capital of Beijing, watching Iron Maiden is unlike anything they will ever have seen before, if only because the cost and bureaucracy of bringing a full show to China — as Maiden did — is prohibitive for most Western bands. It was a similar story when they first played Poland. ‘The Polish audiences were some of the best I’d ever seen,’ Dickinson told Billboard in 1984. ‘I think it’s because they’re so starved for Western entertainment.’ The same could undoubtedly be said of the Chinese audiences last month. For Westerners, spoiled for choice when it comes to stadium rock, it is almost impossible to comprehend fully the impact of seeing a show as energetic and theatrical as Iron Maiden’s for the first time; a flicker of light in a dreary communist world.

This was apparent when I experienced Iron Maiden live for the first time two weeks before the Chinese leg of their world tour — a Herculean undertaking involving the organisation and transportation of hundreds of crew, management, family members and entourage, as well as enough props and set dressing to fill the hold of a Boeing 747. I joined them in Vancouver. At that point they had already been on the road (or, more accurately, in the air) for six weeks, playing to audiences of up to 55,000 people a night in South and North America.

The show, which I watched again in both Beijing and Shanghai, usually opens with a spotlight on Dickinson singing solo while standing behind a smoking cauldron with two fire-topped plinths on either side, which shoot flames almost 20 feet into the air as the guitars come crashing in and the rest of the band run on (for health and safety reasons the pyrotechnics and dry ice were banned in China). The sheer stamina of the six-piece group, comprised of Dickinson, bassist Steve Harris, drummer Nicko McBrain, and guitarists Adrian Smith, Dave Murray and Janick Gers, who are all in their late fifties and early sixties, is remarkable. Despite being diagnosed with cancer of the tongue and undergoing chemotherapy last year, Dickinson still zigzags back and forth across the 50ft-wide stage and takes running jumps off the monitors while Gers, known for his flamboyant performances, repeatedly swings his guitar around his head and throws it into the air.

There are, undeniably, elements that creep into Spinal Tap territory. Midway through each show, for example, a crew member dressed as the band’s zombie-like mascot Eddie ambles on to the stage to have his heart ripped out by Dickinson. But the theatrics are knowing and thrilling. And offstage, the band members couldn’t be more unassuming. Gers, originally from Hartlepool, is soft-spoken and contemplative, while Dickinson has a side gig as a qualified commercial airline pilot and used to work for the now-defunct Icelandic airline Astraeus in his spare time. It is Dickinson who captains the privately chartered 747, ferrying the band and its crew around the world (he delights in getting on the intercom before each flight to talk about crosswinds and jet fuel). When not in the cockpit, he can often be found wandering around the aircraft in his crisp pilot’s uniform.

In Beijing, as in many other cities, there were fans waiting at the airport clutching Maiden records and posters. During a rare sightseeing opportunity, Gers posed for a picture with two young men sporting Iron Maiden T-shirts and long black hair in politically charged Tiananmen Square. Just hours later he was back on stage wielding his Fender Strat while Chinese police stood scattered among the audience, sticking out like sore thumbs in their severe blue jackets and peaked caps against a sea of euphoric metalheads. Although the police rarely interacted with the audience (except to tell one fan repeatedly to put his shirt back on after he removed it in a fit of ecstasy and waved it in the air), their robust presence was reminder enough that this was a surveillance state, and leant great poignancy to the sight of thousands of Chinese fans singing along to the group’s 1993 hit ‘Fear of the Dark’, which includes the lyric: ‘Fear of the dark, fear of the dark, I have a phobia that someone’s always there.’

Unfortunately, for metal fans in places such as Iran, where almost all non-religious music is de facto haram, the opportunity to experience such a show in their own country remains, for the foreseeable future, a pipe dream. In February, reports emerged that members of an Iranian band called Confess had been arrested on charges that included ‘advertising against the system’ and ‘writing anti-religious lyrics’, which landed them in solitary confinement facing lengthy jail sentences if not execution. In the same month, authorities in Egypt apparently tried to shut down an underground metal concert on the basis that it was not only Satanist but also ‘a Western conspiracy to corrupt young Egyptians’, according to a local online news outlet.

Not that any of this will change the attitude of the West’s self-appointed metropolitan tastemakers, who sneer at metal’s working-class roots, melodramatic stage antics and anthemic choruses. But it is precisely these elements that authoritarian regimes find so threatening: thousands of potentially disenfranchised young men exorcising their aggression in the mosh pit while discovering the power of their collective voice as they sing along to tracks encompassing everything from politics (think Black Sabbath’s ‘War Pigs’) to the occult.

Of course, metalheads aren’t the only ones fighting for artistic freedom but they are at the forefront of the battle. And, on stage as well as off, they sure are making a hell of a lot more noise than anyone else.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10

Show comments
  • red2black

    Mainstream Metal may have helped to break down barriers, but it also spawned a multitude of sub-genres, including National Socialist Black Metal.

    • Ridcully

      Fortunately, few people take that bunch of saddoes seriously, including mainstream rock fans who mock them relentlessly

      • Michael H Kenyon

        Says the person with a picture of Gandalf as their avatar.

        • Ridcully

          Actually it’s Mustrum Ridcully from Terry Pratchett;s “Discworld” novels. yes, I’m a self-confessed geek, but I’m not a National Socialist, which is why I consider that groups of people as saddoes, rather than their musical preferences.

          • Michael H Kenyon

            Sounds like the narcissism of minor differences to me, but I take your point. NS Black Metalist have to be European, and barely fits with the unfashionable, good-humoured, and, dare I say it, Conservative nature of British heavy rock. Iron Maiden should receive gongs for raising awareness of British history (many a schoolboy learned their history from “The Trooper”, etc.), and could warrant the Queen’s Award for Industry regarding global record and ticket sales over the past 35 years. Not my sort of thing at this end of life, but some years ago I had to take junior, and it was safer than a football match, and as much a pantomime as a rock concert.

          • Jingleballix

            Indeed………rock music is show business…… much as any other genre.

      • red2black

        Pleased to hear it. (no pun intended)

      • magi83

        Metal as a genre jumped the shark around two decades ago and now it’s just another hipster alternative subculture (and a particularly embarrassing one at that).

        NSBM amounts mostly to terrible Oi! punk influenced crap. There were a few noteworthy acts that are lumped in with it such as Burzum and Graveland although that’s more to do with the political views of their frontmen than the actual content of the music. BM always dabbled in taboo subjects and a general exploration of occultism and pre-Christian culture, mysticism and spirituality would inevitably lead to some flirting with NS ideology.

  • Mike Seely

    Great article! Thank you.

  • Jingleballix

    Bruce Springsteen played West Berlin in summer 1988………..there was an even bigger crowd on the other side of the Wall……….

    ………it was mainly the young who brought down the East German regime – Gorbachev had told Honecker to ‘let it go’ – many of the oldies had gotten used to the dullness of their lives, but the young wanted to listen to rock music and travel.

    [ Incidentally, Honecker’s widow – evil, ideological b**** – died recently. ]

    • The_Common_Potato

      Currently listening to Beyond the Realms of Death.

      • Jingleballix

        By Judas Priest??

        • The_Common_Potato

          That’s the band, yup.

          • Jingleballix

            Enjoyed them……..even if they became a bit cliched…..

            ……..K.K. and Glen were excellent guitarists – perhaps not in the Page, Iommi, Blackmore league, but still pretty damn good.

            Rob Halford lived round the corner from me……when he was there.

          • The_Common_Potato

            My favourite band is Rush.

          • Jingleballix

            Yes…….always loved them…….perhaps the best all-round musicians of the lot.

            Well, I say ‘always’, their stuff 1985 to 2005 left me cold really……..but the 8-9 albums prior to that are still listened to regularly.

          • The_Common_Potato

            Currently listening to Machine Head.

          • Jingleballix

            ……….apparently……….they all went out to Montreux.

          • The_Common_Potato

            Did they? I wonder where that is. I’m too Lazy to look it up… Just stay in bed.

            I once got Gillan’s autograph. Glover merely told me to F off, when I asked for his. To quote: “F off, kid.” I had just seen Rainbow, at the Rainbow theatre.

  • Bill Kendall

    Good aticle thank you, Rock music has always been strong and has it’s loyal fans since the late 60s.

    “People try to take my soul away,

    but I don’t hear the rap that they all say

    They try to tell us we don’t belong,

    that’s alright, we’re millions strong

    This is my music, it makes me proud,

    these are my people and this is my crowd”


  • Chris

    “Why do authoritarian regimes fear metalheads?”

    Why would an authoritarian regime ever fear a musical genre that lionises disaffection, defiance, independence, and heroism? Yes, heavy metal is sometimes absurd and escapist, but, as Tolkien (the literary patron saint of the genre) once asked: who fears escapism more than jailers?

    m/ >_< m/

  • ossettian

    Music for bedwetters.

  • The_Common_Potato

    Yeah! Headbang! The_Common_Potato RAAAAARRRRKKKKS: 🙂

    I’ll shag my goat.

  • The_Common_Potato

    Sadly, I can no longer RAAAAAAAAKKKK: my hair’s fallen out.

  • Maiden rules and always will