It was confirmed yesterday that presenter Emma Barnett is to leave the Today programme, and focus her talents instead on a new multi-platform programme for the BBC starting early next year. What this new show actually involves, and exactly which platforms it will be spreading itself across, remains a mystery. (I think multi-platform is just a fancy way of saying ‘podcast’.) But I’m afraid I can’t say I am sorry to hear of her departure.
Like many formerly essential BBC properties, in the last decade or so Today has gone from a ‘must listen’ to a ‘must avoid’
Today has had a unique spot in the current affairs firmament since its inception. It will – staggeringly – reach its 70th birthday next year. But like many formerly essential BBC properties, in the last decade or so it has gone from a ‘must listen’ to a ‘must avoid’.
Actually, ‘must avoid’ is too strong; I find that it simply no longer occurs to me to tune in. I was always a Radio 2 breakfast show man – and don’t get my motor revving on what’s happened to that – but I could be, and frequently was, tempted to twiddle my dial to Today when especially big or interesting news stories were in the air. Now? I find the thought never arises.
On the rare occasions when I did encounter the show during Barnett’s short tenure – just over two years – she struck me as a bad fit. The long shadow of John Humphrys still hangs over Today. Humphrys, like Jeremy Paxman, could be combative and impatient with guests, but you always felt that they deserved it. With Barnett, it feels like she is doing what is expected. She has had some spectacular encounters of the ‘when did you stop beating your wife?’ variety, not least of which was her interview with Kemi Badenoch a few weeks ago. She opened with the inane bleat of ‘Are you willing to make people homeless in the name of national defence?’, and things didn’t improve from there.
It strikes me that Barnett is just not a morning person, not a bright sunbeam of the dawn. While previous holders of her position like Sarah Montague or Sue MacGregor did occasionally get quite firm, they sounded like they wanted to be there. The Barnett vibe is more teenage bedhead, of the grouchy, ‘I’ve just woken up, Mum’ variety.
But the problems of Today cannot be laid at the door of any individual, and are not entirely the fault of the BBC. Many long-standing institutions are not equipped for the modern era. In an age of clipped-up current affairs ‘content’, shouty encounters between journalists and public figures are ten-a-penny. Younger readers won’t believe me, but these occasions used to be rare. Now? You’ll see about 20 before midday.
The main problem? The BBC shot itself in both feet by succumbing to the fashionable nonsense that swallowed up progressive politics in the early part of the last decade. It had, of course, always been left-liberal, but when truly potty ideas became part of that mix it didn’t even try to resist. We are all familiar with its long list of scandals in the period – the Jewish bus slur, its unquestioning adoption of transgenderism as a jolly good idea, the Gaza coverage provided by satellites of terrorists. Losing your authority is a disaster for any news organisation, but the BBC gaily threw away its gold standard reputation as if it didn’t matter. It is still purveying identity hokum – it recently published a very spurious article on ‘transphobia’ in football crowds.
And why? Well, because everybody else was doing it, Miss. Now, it was hardly a shock that the Beeb – whose staff, as anybody who has worked there can tell you, ranges from centrist extremist to extremist extremist – is an organ of the progressive establishment. What is galling, considering its funding model, is that it jumped into the truly cranky fringes the moment they became the mode. This has marked the BBC as unreliable and untrustworthy – the worst thing any news outlet can be. Find Out Now’s 2025 survey discovered, for the first time, that an outright majority do not trust its news content.
The BBC has let itself slide into the worst possible place in the new media era – too brain-numbingly PC for people like me, too milquetoast for progressives in comparison to full-throated, partisan podcasts from ex-staffers like The News Agents. No wonder Emma Barnett sounds so crabby.












