World

The great paradox of Western civilisation

17 November 2026

10:20 PM

17 November 2026

10:20 PM

When Collins Dictionary named ‘mogging’ as its word of the year, it seemed another triumph for the vocabulary of adolescent narcissism. To ‘mog’ someone is to outshine them, preferably while making them look inadequate. Harmless internet slang, perhaps. But language often reveals more about our culture than we care to admit.

Behind this obsession with comparison lies something more troubling: a world view that increasingly reduces human beings to little more than sophisticated lumps of biomass. According to fashionable materialists, consciousness is a biological accident, free will an illusion and morality an evolutionary convenience. We are simply collections of particles, programmed by chemistry and condemned to a brief existence before oblivion.

In my work with teenagers and students, I see the consequences of this philosophy. If life has no intrinsic meaning, why not spend our allotted years maximising pleasure, accumulating possessions and outperforming everyone else?

Here lies the great paradox of modern Western civilisation. We worship individual autonomy while increasingly embracing a philosophy that denies genuine free choice. We celebrate human dignity while insisting that human beings are merely biological machines. We demand moral responsibility while questioning whether morality has any objective foundation.

A civilisation cannot survive indefinitely on enlightened self-interest alone

Is it any wonder that so many young people struggle with anxiety, isolation and a desperate search for meaning? We have stripped society of the language of transcendence and then expressed astonishment when people feel spiritually empty.

Of course, religious belief is no guarantee of virtue, nor is atheism a barrier to moral seriousness. But a society that abandons the possibility of absolute truth, justice and human dignity risks reducing morality to little more than personal preference. When ‘your truth’ and ‘my truth’ replace the search for the truth, what remains to distinguish right from wrong beyond convenience or consensus?


This brings us to a distinction that may explain much of our present social malaise: the difference between a contract and a covenant.

A social contract is fundamentally transactional. I respect your rights because you respect mine. We agree to certain rules because cooperation serves our mutual interests. It is an excellent basis for commerce, traffic regulations and the machinery of government. But it is a poor foundation for civilisation.

Contracts tell us what we can demand from one another. They cannot adequately explain what we owe one another, particularly when there is nothing in it for us.

Why sacrifice for a stranger? Why care for the vulnerable when they can offer nothing in return? Why remain loyal to a community when abandoning it might be more profitable? A covenant offers a different answer.

Unlike a contract, a covenant is not merely an arrangement between competing interests. It is a commitment rooted in shared identity, moral obligation and a purpose greater than ourselves.

We see it whenever people volunteer their time, care for neighbours or accept responsibilities without expecting repayment. Such behaviour is not simply a calculation of personal advantage. It reflects an understanding that belonging carries obligations. A contract asks: ‘What’s in it for me?’ A covenant asks: ‘What can we build together?’

This need not be an argument for imposing religious doctrine. A pluralistic society must accommodate different beliefs about God and existence. But it should also recognise that human beings are not merely consumers, competitors or economic units. We are creatures who search for meaning, seek purpose and instinctively sense that our lives ought to matter.

The religious understanding of humanity offers something particularly powerful: that each person possesses a dignity beyond price and a potential that cannot be measured by material success. Life is not necessarily a zero-sum competition in which another person’s gain diminishes our own. Indeed, the greatest achievements of civilisation have come not from people asking how much they could extract from society, but how much they could contribute to it.

The 20th century gave us ample reason to distrust grand ideological certainties. But in fleeing absolutism, we risk embracing a relativism that leaves us with nothing worth defending.

A civilisation cannot survive indefinitely on enlightened self-interest alone. It needs people prepared to do the right thing even when it is inconvenient, costly or personally unrewarding. Contracts may be sufficient to run a marketplace. But only covenants can sustain a civilisation.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.


Close