Books

Shunned, slighted and starving in Sheffield — the Indian immigrants who have become Britain’s untouchables

27 June 2015

9:00 AM

27 June 2015

9:00 AM

Novels of such scope and invention are all too rare; unusual, too, are those of real heart, whose characters you grow to love and truly care for. The Year of the Runaways has it all. The action spans continents, taking in a vast sweep of politics, religion and immigration; it also examines with tenderness and delicacy the ties that bind us, whether to family, friends or fellow travellers. Judges of forthcoming literary prizes need look no further.

Rose Tremain’s The Road Home described the experience of an Eastern European immigrant arriving to look for work in England. The book (which is among Tremain’s finest) was a powerful corrective to the notion that such migrants have an easy time of things. But the lot of the European casual worker is one of unimaginable luxury when compared with that of immigrants from India. The Year of the Runaways shows what life might be like for a group of such workers. I say ‘workers’, but there’s the rub. The three young men at the centre of the story spend almost all their time and energy looking for employment, but their dodgy legal status, youth and isolation make theirs a largely thankless task. Without recourse to the benefit system enjoyed by their European counterparts, these characters risk starvation if they cannot find work.


The story begins as our three heroes arrive in Sheffield. In order to get there, one of the men has undertaken a sham marriage so as to qualify for citizenship; another has obtained a student visa, while the third has no papers at all. His life is further complicated by being from the Chamar caste. I hadn’t known that the caste system extended beyond the Hindu faith, but here it is, among Sikhs, a source of violence, prejudice and exclusion. The accident of his birth has already brought him almost unimaginable grief in India. In England, too, he is shunned and slighted.

Interwoven with life in a northern town are the three family histories in Punjab which have brought these young men here. In each case unemployment at home and a series of misfortunes — some hardly bearable in their horror — bring them to the decision to try their luck elsewhere. One has sold a kidney to buy his ticket. Loan sharks are involved. Families are depending on them for support. The promise of riches in England glitters in the far distance, yet the gap between their expectation of the joy and wealth they will find here and their lived experience is desperate. It’s Dick Whittington for the 21st century.

A fourth strand of the story concerns a pious Sikh girl from Croydon, Narinder. For complicated reasons, she marries one of the three so that he may come to England. She is a wonderful creation: kind, stubborn, modest and clever. She never does what you want her to do. Her fate is to become entwined with another of the group in a most touching and unexpected way. The novel closes with a glimpse of Narinder in Kanyakumari, at the very southernmost tip of India. For sheer emotion and vertigo-inducing anxiety, the scene ranks with Tess putting the letter under Angel Clare’s door, or Omar Sharif catching sight of Julie Christie on a moving bus in the film of Dr Zhivago. You cry because of the terribleness of it, but also because you just don’t want this book to end. Sunjeev Sahota is an absolutely wonderful writer. It is amazing that this book, so rich, so absorbing, so deftly executed, should be only his second. I doubt if I’ll read a better novel this year.

Available from the Spectator Bookshop, £13.49 Tel: 08430 600033

Subscribe to The Spectator Australia today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Subscribe – Try a month free


Show comments
  • Gilbert White

    Will be revered as a masterpiece by one or two people on the night shift at Broadcasting House.

    • The Bogle

      And will become a likely choice for Book at Bedtime.

  • Smiffy51

    How on earth did illegal immigrants come to be classed as ‘heroes’?

    • Sue Smith

      The bleeding heart brigade has attempted to change the language and the social mindset.

      Sunday night on Australian TV we watched a documentary about Nigeria. In their capital city there are marauding gangs of men involved in crime, protection rackets and drugs. It occurred to my husband myself that it’s these same men who are able to afford ‘passage’ via human traffikers to Europe and the UK and that’s the demographic you’re getting. Nobody else can afford it!!!

      Far from being heroes, these illegal immigrants are criminals themselves and the REAL refugees – women and children (families) – are left behind at the mercy of vicious killers. Soon you’ll feel the wrath and consequences of these illegal immigrants from Nigeria and surrounding countries. If you don’t have a spine you take the ongoing pain.

      Please don’t EVER expect the BBC to even discuss this, let alone “get it”. In their gated, electronic community such things are beyond their ken.

  • XH558

    The story begins as our three heroes arrive in Sheffield. In order to get there, one of the men has undertaken a sham marriage so as to qualify for citizenship; another has obtained a student visa, while the third has no papers at all.

    So it is a detective novel?

  • MrJones

    If you had 100,000 men like that in Sheffield they could create quite a demand for cheap prostitution.

  • stephengreen

    Yes, doesn’t sound like it will be making my bookshelf, but it does give a mainstream hint at an issue rarely touched upon by media sources: the high levels of nepotism and discrimination among Hindus (and Sikhs) in this country. The counter-Jihad brigade are fond of castigating Muslims and holding these other ethnic groups up as exemplars. Truth is, not so much, as a quick Google will inform. The unique thing about Western culture and therefore Western people is their looser kin networks and the individualism that created our cultural heritage, explaining much of our civilizational success. But also now the Achilles’ heel that foretells our (and arguably the world’s) doom.

  • Ipsedixit

    Is there a chapter in which they find life so dreadful in England that they decide to go back home?

Close