Grade: D
Yes, it’s porky Sam from Essex, with his body issues and his complex gender pronouns and his endless narcissistic banalities, his depthless self-importance.
This is Smith’s fourth studio album in a career that seems to be nosing a little downhill, mercifully – although it will still sell by the million worldwide. He has recently decided he is genderqueer, rather than just gay. He says he feels like a woman. Me too, mate – but what’s a boy to do?
The good things? Just one. He has a pleasant and flexible tenor voice which, when unadulterated, is capable of carrying a tune – if there were, y’know, tunes. And that’s it. The music, with its usual plethora of co-writers and co-producers and collaborations with people you’d rather not hear from, such as Ed Sheeran, is in two senses a rebuttal of the wisdom of crowds. Astoundingly repetitive even by the standards of modern pop and EDM, nursery-rhyme melodies are sellotaped to cleverly, often sparsely, manufactured beats.
You will never hear a song more boring than ‘Gimme’: it makes ‘Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep’ sound like the Mahavishnu Orchestra. The single ‘Unholy’ is unabashed Europop, while ‘I’m Not Here to Make Friends’ (with its obnoxious video) is a four-second ad jingle fleshed out for eternity.
The lyrics are the usual lachrymose self-pity and inane grandstanding in equal measure. On the gospel-tinged ‘Love Me More’, he sings: ‘Every day I’m trying not to hate myself.’ Then stop trying, Sam, and join us.
Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.
You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first month for free, then just $2 a week for the remainder of your first year.