Music

Why I’m glad my piano teacher spent more time chatting than teaching

Without Mrs Oates I might have become a better pianist - but I'm pleased I didn't

17 October 2015

8:00 AM

17 October 2015

8:00 AM

At the entrance to Marylebone railway station is an old piano that anyone can play. Unfortunately, whoever had this sweet idea can’t be bothered to fix the broken notes. Even so, about once a fortnight, on my way back from visiting my mother in Gerrards Cross, I put down my shopping bag and bash out Chopin’s Waltz in C-sharp minor.

As I do, I invariably think about Mrs Irene Oates, the first proper eccentric I met. She was my only piano teacher and I’m grateful to her. On the other hand I’m not very good, even by amateur standards, and she’s partly to blame.

When I was 11, my mother told me that she’d spoken on the telephone to a lady who was going to teach my sister and me the piano. ‘She’s a real talker,’ she added, slightly apprehensively. My parents weren’t voluble people.

The apprehension was justified. Once a week my father would drive me to my teacher’s terraced house in Maidenhead. Oates was an appropriate name for her because he knew that, like the polar explorer, I ‘may be some time’. Often I’d return after an hour and 40 minutes, most of it spent chatting. My father was always furious.

But for me it was bliss. Mrs Oates would fling open the door and push me into her ‘drawing room’, which was the size of a teabag but decorated in the style of the Second Empire. She was a middle-aged lady with red curly hair who waved her arms around a lot, her diamanté reading glasses swinging furiously as she tottered on perilous heels. She was big-boned and not naturally graceful; there was always a danger that a bust of Beethoven might go flying. Had that happened, it would have been an epic disaster. Every misfortune was a crisis, just as everything nice was greeted with a shriek of ‘Oh, goody!’


Mrs Oates had a Yorkshire accent that veered from broad to genteel. But before her divorce she had lived in California, and there was a whiff of Hollywood about her. Music was her ‘passion’, she declared, and it was true: she would display her love of opera by throwing back her head and yelling ‘Figaro-Figaro-Figaro-Figaro-Figaro-Figaro’ from The Barber of Seville.

All this hysteria I loved. The anxiety, less so. Mrs Oates adored her dozen or so pupils but worried that we might let her down by scoring less than top marks in an Associated Board exam. Her vicarious pre-exam nerves freaked us all out.

Even scarier was her annual recital. The parents were squeezed into corners and fed finger-sandwiches and pink fondant patisseries. ‘I have extremely good taste,’ she liked to say, and part of that taste was worship of daintiness. But behind the gentility was panic: every wrong note was a dagger to her heart.

At the end of the recital she would perform something herself. ‘After those fancy cakes I was expecting delicate Mozart,’ said my mother. Instead, Mrs Oates launched into a lush arrangement of the Italian song ‘Sorrento’, swaying over the keyboard to emphasise the ‘very deep feeling’ she was injecting into the piece.

She taught me until I went to university, and by the end I’d begun to grasp that her life was full of fear. She struggled to bring up two boys on a miserable income. She hinted that her ex-husband was ‘difficult’. Then came the news that he’d stabbed his second wife to death in a Los Angeles parking lot. After two years in jail he was killed by another prisoner.

For a woman who was plunged into despair if her poodle caught a cold, Mrs Oates dealt with this horror with surprising calm. But the strain was showing. Her last days were unhappy, I think, and I’m ashamed that when she died 15 years ago I hadn’t seen her for over a decade. I kept meaning to, but never got round to it. She just didn’t strike me as the sort of person who would die.

Was she a good piano teacher? It’s difficult to say. She had no special insights into technique and accuracy wasn’t her strong point. It was years before I learned that when a composer writes l’istesso tempo he does not mean ‘play listlessly’, as Mrs Oates insisted, miming listlessness by flopping about like a rag doll.

But then I remember the time she put on a record of Liszt’s Totentanz and marched around the room bawling out its Dies Irae theme, bracelets slipping down her arm as she ‘conducted’ the orchestra. Mrs Oates taught me that it’s OK for adults to become childishly excited about classical music. If I’d gone to a more conventional teacher I might have become a better pianist — but I’m so glad I didn’t.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10


Show comments
  • Philip Fryer

    This is a great piece, Damian. I remember her, of course, and the scarcely disguised rivalry between her and the teacher I sent my children to. But rivalries could be humane and entertaining in those days, unlike many today which seem so vituperative. I admire also how you value her human contribution so much higher than any greater technique she might have ideally been able to bring to you. And thank you for bringing a splendid character to life in my memory again.

    • Damian Thompson

      Philip, thank you so much for the advice you gave me while I was writing the piece! It’s a cheerful thought that, even today, I can ring my English teacher and mentor when I’m stuck 🙂

      • ed t

        and then I woke up and found to my astonishment it was all a dream…

        My piano teacher turfed me out as a waste of space after a couple of months. I didn’t mind ’cause her house and living room especially smelled rather off, but in the end I felt guilty because her retired husband Doug was a Japanese POW vet and money was tight- but she was a lady of integrity and wouldn’t have me loafing on my mother’s dime so to speak. I still remember her lanky, scraggy dog, responsible for a certain undefinable segment of the smell.

      • Philip Fryer

        You are so welcome. I love that too. Good old FB!

  • dep

    Lovely article.

  • trace9

    Had you no piano at home, Dammo, we did – but familiarity bred That c-word.. Once I was ‘tested’ for tutoring, but told to come back when my fingers could span an octave. As enough of my youthful energies were being ‘channelled’, I made sure they never quite did. Do now though, but there’s always the CD rack. – Like so much in Dammo’s life, Oates seems a mite curate’s eggy..

  • Fraser Bailey

    I often recall my own piano teacher, Mr Chadwick, who would begin every lesson with a short discussion on Clive of India, and who still celebrated Empire Day. He lived alone in a large-ish and rather creepy house. I was so desperate to learn at the age of six that I fell to the floor at my parents’ feet, begging for lessons in the belief that after a couple of weeks I would be able to play like my father. How wrong I was. I currently play every day and derive great enjoyment from it.

    • Damian Thompson

      I love the Clive of India detail. I also play every day and, now that *finally* I have met someone who teaches me almost magical tricks of fingering, am enjoying it more than ever before.

      • Sanctimony

        Magical tricks of fingering…. Wow, the mind boggles…

  • I thought Gladys Mills was your piano teacher.

    • Sanctimony

      So, all you tediously pious branleurs continue to chip away with you infantile comments and bogus chummery…. claqueurs, as someone once dubbed you… although I haven’t seen much of Mathatmacoatmabag lately… hope that he creeps out of the woodwork soon….

      • Phil

        Fr Rosina warned:
        “When ‘faithful Catholics’ you use filthy, condemnatory language, you will be blocked! Visit sites that use such tactics & go to confession.”

    • Phil

      No that was Jadis’s teacher. Gladys Mills was more chubby than “big-boned”.

      On the Internet…
      …..“The ugly are one of the few groups against whom it is still legal to discriminate”
      — The Economist, Dec. 22, 2007

  • Phil

    “…bracelets slipping down her arm as she ‘conducted’ the orchestra.”

    Nice touch – the kind of description that makes characters come alive for the reader…and she certainly sounds like a real character.

  • Velo

    When I was a child, my siblings and I were taught piano by a Polish exile by the name of Bop, which is very appropriate when you consider that he was a musician. There’s a retrospective about Leonard Bernstein on BBC4 now. It’s tasteful fare by the Beeb’s standards, including some Bach to stir the soul.

    • Damian Thompson

      Mrs Oates was a huge Lenny fan!

  • polistra24

    Love it.

    Instead of teaching you how to play the piano, she was teaching you how to play life.

    You became a life-ist instead of a pianist.

    We need more life-ist teachers!

  • Morseman

    What pleasure to read this tale!
    People like your eccentric piano teacher add a sparkle to life.

  • Redsfanx

    Mrs. Oates taught you the love of music which is what life is about.

Close